Search
Penn National Insurance cover

Claims Representative II

PublishedPublished: 11/10/2026
| |
$52,000 - $72,000 per year

The Claims Representative II investigates, evaluates and resolves assigned claims in a timely and accurate manner in order to achieve a best practices type settlement within legal statutes, policy provisions and Company standards of performance.

This is a hybrid role reporting to the Waukesha, WI office.

POSITION COMPETENCIES

  • Business Acumen
  • Negotiation
  • Results Oriented
  • Time & Priority Management
  • Decision Making

ESSENTIAL DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES

  • Prepares claim file documentation accurately and completely, to include all relevant oral and written statements, photos, facts and environmental factors present at the scene of the accident.
  • Makes appropriate contacts and negotiating with policyholders, claimants, third parties, medical and legal professionals in the processes of arbitration, litigation, subrogation, contribution and salvage.
  • Achieves a best practices type settlement in the disposition of assigned claims, including assessing all costs and determining first and third party liabilities associated with the settlement of auto property damage, non-complex workers' compensation, property losses and simple bodily injury claims.
  • Effectively identifies and pursues subrogation and salvage opportunities, when available.
  • Performs basic and intermediate claims handling duties on assigned claims in a timely manner.
  • Verifies coverage and policy provisions in order to identify the claim's insurability or compensability.
  • Takes responsibility for handling and resolving policyholder/self-insured/claimant problems or requests.
  • Analyzes and resolves coverage and liability issues or questions.
  • Gathers and evaluates factual information that enhances identification of underlying problems or opportunities pertaining to assigned claims.
  • Setting or adjusting reserves in accordance with the degree of liability and value of the claim.

ADDITIONAL RESPONSIBILITIES

  • At the direction of the Team Leader, may perform limited field work, limited claim handling on workers' compensation lost time claims of low exposure/low complexity, as well as low exposure/low complexity bodily injury liability claims.
  • Generates alternative solutions to problems or situations involving assigned claims.
  • Performs other duties as may be assigned by the CSO Team Leader Multi/WC Claims Service Office Manager II, or CSO Team Leader

SPECIAL RELATIONSHIPS

  • The Claims Representative II has direct contact and interacts with all levels of personnel within the Claims Service Office
  • Interacts with underwriting personnel regarding claim issues
  • Interact with agents
  • Has direct contact with policyholders/claimants, third parties, medical/legal professionals, vendors

QUALIFICATIONS

Education/Credentials

  • Bachelor's degree preferred
  • Adjuster's license or be willing to obtain one as required

Experience

  • Successful completion of Claims Representative II Trainee curriculum or a minimum of 1 year experience in a property/casualty claims handling position.
  • Experience in a customer service oriented position preferred.

Technical/Professional Knowledge

  • Effective communication skills, both oral and written
  • Effective inter-personal skills
  • Effective organization skills, with the ability to work independently
  • Must be detail oriented, as assigned work requires significant attention to detail
  • Personal Computer skills, with an emphasis on Microsoft products
  • Ability to work within a team-oriented, fast-paced, customer-focused environment
  • Basic understanding of tort and state laws applicable to assigned claims
  • Basic understanding of the Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act, insurance policy coverages and provisions, and medical, legal, automotive and construction terminology

    The compensation has been carefully determined by considering a variety of important factors, including skill sets, experience, training, and certifications. With these considerations in mind, the estimated hiring range is $52,000 - $72,000. Additionally, you may be able to participate in our annual incentive program, depending on eligibility under the plan.

JOB REQUIREMENTS (as required by ADA – Americans with Disabilities Act)

  • This position is primarily a sedentary position that requires occasional standing and walking throughout the office environment.
  • Must be able to perform computer-based tasks and access digital information necessary for job duties, including through the use of assistive technologies.
  • Must be able to complete computer-based tasks and utilize office equipment as needed to perform essential job functions.
  • Must be able to access and enter information accurately using automated systems.
  • Must be able to communicate effectively with internal and external clients using telephone, electronic, or other communication systems.
  • Must be able to present information to individuals and groups.
  • Must be able to interpret and apply concepts that may or may not be based upon established guidelines.
  • Must be able to maintain acceptable attendance and adhere to scheduled work hours.
  • Must be dependable and able to adhere to scheduled work hours

Salary range

  • $52,000 - $72,000 per year